Posts

Showing posts with the label pen-and-paper

Review: FlowDoku for iPhone and iPad

Image
Just when you thought that Sudoku had been beaten to death, here comes FlowDoku by HapaFive Games, which turns the concept on its head to produce an excitingly original new puzzle. To be clear, the only thing this game shares with Sudoku is the basic premise of placing symbols on a grid so that certain requirements are met on every row, column, and box. That's pretty much the end of similarities. In Sudoku you have 9 different symbols, which must not be repeated; in FlowDoku, you have a smaller number of symbols, some of which must be repeated a given number of times. The second rule is the stroke of genius: the symbols that appear multiple times in a box, must be next to each other. This second rule makes the solving strategies very different from Sudoku, and allows for a great variety of logic deductions. At the beginning of each puzzle you have a number of givens; it goes without saying that there is only one way to fill the grid following the rules. So e.g. you need to get f...

Update: Fields 1.0.4

Image
Fields by Kevin Langdon has just been updated and it addressed the criticism I made in my previous review . In its first release the game showed a lot of potential: the flower theme fits perfectly the mechanics of the puzzles. Unfortunately, I was disappointed that some puzzles didn't have a unique solution. I'm happy to see that this issue has been fully fixed in the update. There are 100 new puzzles to solve, and two extra packs of 100 puzzles of size 4x5 and 5x6 that can be unlocked through in-app purchases. Hopefully more packs at larger sizes will be available in a future update. Now that the puzzles have a unique solution, they are a joy to solve. I wish the user interface were just a bit smoother in the transitions, but apart from that the game is strongly recommended. ©2013 Nicola Salmoria. Unauthorized use and/or duplication without express and written permission is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Ni...

Review: Takuzu for iPhone and iPad

Image
Takuzu is a fake Japanese sounding name for a puzzle that has often been described as "binary Sudoku" (even if it's quite different from Sudoku). Indeed, it is also known as Binairo , or simply as Binary Puzzle . It is played on a square grid of variable size; the iPhone version supports from 4x4 to 8x8, while the iPad version from 6x6 to 12x12. The rules are: 1) Each row and column must contain the same number of 0s and 1s 2) There can be no more than two consecutive 0s or 1s. 3) There cannot be two identical rows or columns. Rule 3) is not intuitive and is often unnecessary. I didn't find the puzzles particularly enjoyable. The easiest ones felt like mechanical applications of the basic tips , which are trivial corollaries of the rules. In the harder ones, I got often stuck with no apparent way to proceed through logic deductions, the only way forward being to make a guess. Of course I might have missed something, however it doesn't look like this puzzle ha...

Review: Conceptis Slitherlink for iPhone and iPad

Image
Conceptis Slitherlink is the latest in a series of puzzle apps for iPhone and iPad developed by Conceptis , a company which specialises in classic style, pen-and-paper logic puzzles. I've written in the past that Slitherlink is one of my favorite puzzles, so I've played many implementations of it. Some versions are good, most notably the one in Simon Tatham's Portable Puzzle Collection which features many interesting variants. All the ones I tried so far, however, lacked a feature which I consider critical in the transition from pen and paper to touch screen. I'm happy to say that Conceptis' version has that feature. It is actually disabled by default, but after enabling it in the options screen, here is what you see when you start a puzzle: See? The edges around the 0 have been automatically crossed out. The game will automatically cross out all edges that cannot contain the path according to the game rules. At long last! Isn't this what computers are suppo...

Review: Fields for iPhone and iPad

Image
Fields by Kevin Langdon is a restyling of the classic Fillomino logic puzzle, which is published by many magazines. I like when developers take their time to rethink how a classic puzzle is played, in order to make it work better on a touch screen. On paper, Fillomino is typically played by filling with lines and numbers a white grid, like this image taken from janko.at shows. This works on a magazine, but it would look pretty boring on an iPhone screen. Fields adds colours, by associating each number with a flower (except for 1 which becomes just rocks). To fill an empty cell, you just drag from a populated cell nearby. The goal is to completely cover the grid with flowers, in such a way that the size of each area matches the numbers given. So in the image below, we want to have 4 sunflowers and 2 violets. One thing that isn't immediately apparent is that the dragging you make doesn't need to be a single motion; so in the case above you can drag right from the 4 to colour ...

Review: Simon Tatham's Portable Puzzle Collection

Image
Often, puzzle collections aren't very good. I prefer games that are focused on doing a single thing in the best possible way. Simon Tatham's Portable Puzzle Collection , however, is a different story. It is more than a classic: it's a piece of history. The "Portable" in the name doesn't refer to mobile devices , but rather to software portability . It was initially created in 2004, before the iPhone even existed, and initially it ran only on Unix and Windows. I used to play it 8 years ago, on a Palm Tungsten E2 , using a stylus . The portable collection consists of good logic puzzles, some well known, other less known, and it's still growing and being maintained . Currently it includes 36 different puzzles. The collection was actually already present on the App Store, under various names, both as a whole and as single games; as far as I know, in most cases this was done without acknowledgements to Simon Tatham . At long last, Greg Hewgill has done a ...

Review: Linesweeper for iPhone and iPad

Image
Stanley Lam has published several puzzle games for iPhone and iPad. They all seem to share a user interface style which I don't really like, though the underlying logic puzzles can be interesting. Linesweeper might be the best of the bunch so far. It is similar to the popular Slitherlink , but different enough to be noteworthy. The puzzle was actually invented a few years ago by +Jak Marshall , as mentioned on his blog . I like closed loop puzzles, my favorite being Monorail , so it should be no surprise that I like Linesweeper too. The play area is a grid containing some numbers. The grid is always square in this implementation of the puzzle, though it doesn't have to be. The goal is to draw a closed loop on the board. The loop cannot pass through cells containing a number. The numbers indicate how many of the 8 neighbouring cells must be crossed by the loop. So the solution to the above puzzle would be: Note that I had put a X between the 4 and 2, to remind that the loop c...

Review: CounterBalancE for iPhone and iPad

Image
CounterBalanceE is a logic puzzle for iPhone and iPad by George Menhorn which was originally released back in 2009. A free version called CounterBalancE Lite is also available. According to the app description, the game was inspired by a puzzle created by Craig Kasper. The concept is pretty good and original. You start with a grid containing some holes and some labelled nodes, like this: You can tap holes to turn them into extra nodes; this will create links to the closest labelled nodes in the same row or column, if they exist. The goal is for the total length of the links starting from each labelled node to be equal to the label of the node. So the solution of the above puzzle would be: Of course this is an easy puzzle; the game contains about 100, of increasing difficulty, with the largest ones using a 9x9 grid. Note that the solution above is not unique, because you could put an extra node in the bottom left corner. However, that node wouldn't contribute to the solution in an...